Learning to smell and describe
Prepare a simple, repeatable comparison.
What you will learn
- Prepare a simple, repeatable comparison.
- Write an observation without confusing it with a preference.
- Reach a conclusion that helps with the next trial.
Describe before identifying
Start with sensations: fresh, dry, damp, bright, dark, smooth, rough. Then look for a family and finally precise references. This progression limits forced answers.
Use a consistent record
Note the date, surface, known dosage, elapsed time, facets, images evoked and intensity. Always using the same structure makes comparisons more useful.
Return to the material
Olfactory memory develops through spaced repetition. Revisit a material several days later without immediately rereading your first notes, then compare.
Prepare the conditions
Avoid starting in an environment saturated with other smells. Label the blotters before the trial and note the time. Two or three careful comparisons are more useful than a long series that is hard to distinguish.
An observation is not a preference
“I perceive a dry, woody facet” describes a sensation. “I find it too dry for me” expresses a preference. Both are useful, provided personal taste is not presented as an objective fault in the fragrance.
What if the words do not come?
Start by comparing two impressions: dry or soft, fresh or warm, light or dense. Then look for a concrete memory. You can write “it reminds me of…” without claiming to identify a material. Precision develops gradually.
Share without steering the answer
Invite the other person to describe before giving your own view. Ask “what has changed since the first trial?”. This wording makes room for a different perception and helps choose the next step in the discovery.
Build a comparison that answers a question
Begin with a limited question: do two perfumes differ mainly in texture, opening or evolution? This intention determines what you record. A session seeking everything at once often produces comments that are difficult to compare. Prepare a short grid, define your words and retain a free field. An unexpected note deserves recording even if it does not immediately answer the question.
The record must allow conditions to be recovered: sample identity or code, support, known quantity and elapsed time. If a datum is missing, state this instead of reconstructing it. Compare at equivalent times and leave breaks. The exercise remains an organised personal observation; it does not become a group study or instrumental measurement simply because you use a numerical table.
Then separate description, interpretation and preference. “I perceive minty freshness” describes an effect; “it comes from peppermint” suggests an origin requiring confirmation. “I prefer it” answers a different question. To conclude, cite a precise observation, formulate a qualification and choose the next check. A well-supported provisional conclusion is more useful than a definitive judgement that cannot be reproduced.
Continue with the materials library
- Peppermint
Distinguish a freshness effect from certain ingredient identification.
- Vetiver
Enrich descriptions of dry texture and depth.
Fictional teaching example
Fictional teaching case — a comparison to repeat
In an invented notebook, A is described immediately and B after a long wait. The student wants to conclude that B is softer. No actual test is presented.
| Sample | Time | Fictional notebook entry | Scope of the record |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | At the start | Bright and zesty | Describes A at the start. |
| B | After an hour | Soft and woody | Describes B later: the times are not comparable. |
Reasoning with commentary
- Elapsed time differs: the comparison may confuse evolution with a difference between the creations.
- Define “soft”: supple texture, low intensity and a sweet impression are different things.
- Plan a new comparison at equivalent times and record preference separately without announcing its result.
Good reasoning identifies the interfering variable and prepares a check rather than validating the ranking.
Success criteria
- Propose comparable conditions.
- Define the descriptive term.
- Qualify the conclusion with a limitation.
Useful words
Describing a sensation is not analysing a formula. Write “this reminds me of…” when offering a comparison.
Facet
One aspect of a smell: a single material may suggest lemon, green leaves and wood.
Accord
A blend of materials that creates an overall impression. It can evoke a plant without containing its extract.
Extract
A material obtained from a source through a specific process. The plant name alone is not enough: the part and method matter.
Distillation
Steam carries volatile constituents. After cooling, the watery distillate is separated from the essential oil when present.
Absolute
A fragrant extract obtained through extraction and purification, usually with solvents. It is not an essential oil.
Resin
A plant secretion distinct from needles and wood. Its extract and an essential oil distilled from foliage are not interchangeable.
Try it yourself
How to study this lesson
- Prepare two blotters, a pencil and a space with little ambient scent.
- Briefly smell each blotter, pausing between them.
- Complete the table before consulting the fragrance descriptions.
Test two fragrances on two blotters labelled A and B. For each, note a family, two facets and the intensity at the same moment. Then separate an “I observe” column from an “I prefer” column. Make another brief reading later and choose which you want to explore on skin, giving a precise reason.
Reveal the guidance
- Did I compare the two fragrances after a similar amount of time?
- Is “I don’t like it” a description? No: specify the sensation that bothers you.
- Does my conclusion point to a concrete next step?
Remember
A precise description combines observation, time, vocabulary and personal memory.

